History: Frequently Asked Questions About Lojban

Source of version: 52 (current)

You may also find useful information on the ((FAQ-like Resources)) page. !!Table Of Contents # {ALINK(aname=>general)}General Questions{ALINK} # {ALINK(aname=>resources)}Resources{ALINK} # {ALINK(aname=>technical)}Technical{ALINK} # {ALINK(aname=>status)}Project Status{ALINK} # {ALINK(aname=>historical)}Historical{ALINK} # {ALINK(aname=>pronunciation)}Pronunciation{ALINK} !!{ANAME()}general{ANAME}GENERAL G1. {ALINK(aname=>G1)}Help! I don't speak English!{ALINK} G2. {ALINK(aname=>G2)}What is ''lojban''?{ALINK} G3. {ALINK(aname=>G3)}Who is involved in the Lojban project?{ALINK} G4. {ALINK(aname=>G4)}How many people are there in the Lojban community? How many can use Lojban?{ALINK} G5. {ALINK(aname=>G5)}What is LogFest / jbonunsla ?{ALINK} G6. {ALINK(aname=>G6)}What is the difference between the Reference Grammar and the Complete Lojban Language?{ALINK} G7. {ALINK(aname=>G7)}Is there a more complete introduction to Lojban than this FAQ?{ALINK} !!{ANAME()}resources{ANAME}RESOURCES R1. {ALINK(aname=>R1)}What is the best way to start learning Lojban?{ALINK} R2. {ALINK(aname=>R2)}How can I look up ''gismu'', ''lujvo'', and ''cmavo'' when I am translating from lojban?{ALINK} R3. {ALINK(aname=>R3)}Sources of text to read?{ALINK} R4. {ALINK(aname=>R4)}What messages are appropriate for the Lojban List?{ALINK} R5. {ALINK(aname=>R5)}Are there archives? WWW site? ftp site?{ALINK} R6. {ALINK(aname=>R6)}What is available in languages other than English?{ALINK} R7. {ALINK(aname=>R7)}What software is available?{ALINK} !!{ANAME()}technical{ANAME}TECHNICAL T1. {ALINK(aname=>T1)}(Glossary) In English descriptions of ''lojban'', I see ''lojban'' words used, as well as ''lojban'' jargon. What do these words mean?{ALINK} T2. {ALINK(aname=>T2)}How do you borrow words from other languages?{ALINK} T3. {ALINK(aname=>T3)}Isn't it confusing that some ''rafsi'' are identical to ''cmavo''?{ALINK} T4. {ALINK(aname=>T4)} Why do some texts use "h" instead of ''''' (single quote), or have parentheses, or other non-standard conventions?{ALINK} T5. {ALINK(aname=>T5)}Why does it have a special meaning when the ''selbri'' comes first in a sentence?{ALINK} T6. {ALINK(aname=>T6)}Why are there so many words for AND? Why not just let ''.e'' connect two ''sumti'', ''bridi'', ''bridi ''-tails, or anything else?{ALINK} T7. {ALINK(aname=>T7)}Is the 's' at the end of lojbanized names (such as 'noras.') silent?{ALINK} !!{ANAME()}status{ANAME}PROJECT STATUS PS1. {ALINK(aname=>PS1)}What parts of the language are well worked out, and which parts are in flux?{ALINK} PS2. {ALINK(aname=>PS2)}What are the most current revisions of each part of the language descriptions?{ALINK} PS3. {ALINK(aname=>PS3)}What projects are being worked on? When will they be done?{ALINK} PS4. {ALINK(aname=>PS4)}What can I do to help?{ALINK} !!{ANAME()}historical{ANAME}HISTORICAL H1. {ALINK(aname=>H1)}How was the default place structure order of ''sumti'' in a ''selbri'' determined? (There does not appear to be any rhyme or reason for the order of ''sumti'' in many ''gismu''.){ALINK} H2. {ALINK(aname=>H2)}How did the ''gismu'' get made: discussion, etymology examples{ALINK} H3. {ALINK(aname=>H3)}What is the difference between Loglan and Lojban? How is Loglan-82 related?{ALINK} H4. {ALINK(aname=>H4)}Why do older Lojban texts (before 1993) not make much sense sometimes?{ALINK} !! {ANAME()}pronunciation{ANAME}PRONUNCIATION B1. {ALINK(aname=>B1)}I'm not quite sure I understand the written descriptions of how the vowels sound.{ALINK} !!GENERAL {ANAME()}G1{ANAME}G1.__ Help! I don't speak English!__ ;No hablo muy bien inglés...:Puedes contactarte con [mailto:jjllambias@gmail.com|Jorge Llambías] ;Je ne comprends pas très bien l'anglais...:Tu peux contacter [mailto:gregory.dyke@epfl.ch|Greg Dyke] ;Ich verstehe Englisch nicht sehr gut....:Du kannst eine Mail an [mailto:gregory.dyke@epfl.ch|Greg Dyke] senden ;mi na se bangu le glibau:.oiru'e do na nitcu le nu tcidu dei kei ki'u le za'i .ui do pujeca se bangu le jbobau Also, see ((Non-English Lojban Materials|the non-English resources page)) for more listings of non-English lojbanic resources. {ANAME()}G2{ANAME}G2.__ What is ''lojban''?__ Lojban is a carefully constructed ''spoken'', as well as written, language designed in the hope of removing a large portion of the ambiguity from human communication. It was made well-known by a Scientific American article and references in both science fiction and computer publications. Lojban has been built over five decades by dozens of workers and hundreds of supporters. {ANAME()}G3{ANAME}G3.__Who is involved in the Lojban project? __ Key people are listed on the ((Lojbanic Community Links|community)) page. {ANAME()}G4{ANAME}G4.__How many people are there in the Lojban community? How many can use Lojban?__ As of March 2010, close to two thousand people from around the world have developed an interest in Lojban to the point of ordering a [Books|book] or joined a {ALINK(aname=>lists,pagename=>Lojbanic Forums)}Lojban List{ALINK} . At any given time, there are at least 50 to 100 active participants (people who will respond if you ask a question on one of the email lists or in [Lojban IRC|IRC chat room], for example). A number of them can hold a real-time conversation in the language. {ANAME()}G5{ANAME}G5.__What is ((LogFest)) / ((jbonunsla)) ?__ LogFest is the annual gathering of the [The Logical Language Group|Logical Language Group]. We are required by an [Bylaws of The Logical Language Group, Inc.|LLG bylaw] to have an annual meeting. Every year we have a Lojban Convention for any and all in the ((Lojbanic Community Links|community)) who are willing to come. ((LogFest)) was traditionally held at ''lojbab's'' house in Fairfax VA, a suburb of Washington DC, usually over a weekend in July or August. We have typically had around 20 people come for part or all of the weekend. Some of these people are among the more committed Lojbanists, and around half the attendees typically are at beginner skill levels. Usually several people travel a substantial distance in order to attend, and those people are often treated as a guests of honor and are given first consideration for choosing the activities on which we focus. Other than giving those who had to travel furthest preference in picking topics, ((LogFest)) is largely unstructured, in part because we don't know who or how many are coming until a couple of days before things start. ((LogFest)) is what the ((Lojbanic Community Links|community)) chooses to make it. Because the official LLG meeting occurs during ((Logfest)), some of the major decisions affecting the ((Lojbanic Community Links|Lojban community)) tend to get made there. In 2005 and 2006, the annual gatherings started being held at science fiction conventions. The name "((LogFest))" is a holdover from Loglan. The word for it in Lojban is "((jbonunsla))". {ANAME()}G6{ANAME}G6.__What is the difference between the Reference Grammar and the Complete Lojban Language?__ The ((The Lojban Reference Grammar|Reference Grammar)) is online; ((The Complete Lojban Language)) is the hard-copy book version. The terms are sometimes used interchangeably. {ANAME()}G7{ANAME}G7.__Is there a more complete introduction to Lojban than this FAQ?__ Yes! You can read or download ((What Is Lojban?, The Book|What Is Lojban?)), also known as the Level Zero book, edited by Nick Nicholas and John Woldemar Cowan. This book makes an ''excellent'' introduction to lojban. !!RESOURCES {ANAME()}R1{ANAME}R1.__What is the best way to start learning Lojban?__ We recommend the following: # You can read or download ((What Is Lojban?, The Book|What Is Lojban?)), also known as the Level Zero book, edited by Nick Nicholas and John Woldemar Cowan. This book makes an ''excellent'' introduction to lojban. # Work through [http://www.tlg.uci.edu/~opoudjis/lojbanbrochure/lessons/book1.html| Lojban For Beginners]. # Read through the ((The Lojban Reference Grammar|Reference Grammar)) -- reading for concepts, not detail. # Create a cheat sheet with lists of {ALINK(aname=>cmavo)}''cmavo''{ALINK} you're likely to need. # Read and write ((Texts In Lojban|Lojban texts)) using the ((The Lojban Reference Grammar|Reference Grammar)) and your cheat sheets for reference. Post your translated text to the {ALINK(aname=>lists,pagename=>Lojbanic Forums)}Lojban List{ALINK} for feedback. # If you get serious about it, use [http://www.lojban.org/files/software/logflash.zip|Logflash] or [http://quizlet.com/|Quizlet] (register and join the Lojban Group) to help you memorize vocabulary. If some concepts in any of the above resources seem unclear, post your questions to the {ALINK(aname=>lists,pagename=>Lojbanic Forums)}Lojban List{ALINK}. {ANAME()}R2{ANAME}R2.__How can I look up ''{ALINK(aname=>cmavo)}cmavo{ALINK}'' when I am translating from Lojban?__ Use one of these: - print yourself out the [http://www.lojban.org/publications/wordlists/gismu.txt|complete ''gismu'' list], the [http://www.lojban.org/files/draft-dictionary/NORALUJV.txt| current ''lujvo'' list], and the [http://www.lojban.org/publications/wordlists/cmavo.txt| complete ''cmavo'' list] as well as the [http://www.lojban.org/publications/wordlists/rafsi.txt| complete ''rafsi'' list] - refer to the online [http://jbovlaste.lojban.org/|dictionary]. {ANAME()}R3{ANAME}R3.__Sources of text to read?__ There are many. You can find a complete list [Texts in Lojban|here]. Take your pick from original or translated, short or long, prose or poetry, currently-being-worked-on or completed-and-reviewed. The {ALINK(aname=>lists,pagename=>Lojbanic Forums)}Lojban List{ALINK} will have discussion in Lojban from time to time. There is also now a Lojban-only list called {ALINK(aname=>jbosnu,pagename=>Lojbanic Forums)}''jbosnu''{ALINK} ("Lojbanic Discussers"). {ALINK(aname=>JL)}''ju'i lobypli''{ALINK} (Attention! Lojbanic Users) usually have several examples of commented text, though early issues may have some obsolete words or usages. Other Lojbanists publish Web pages, some with Lojban texts and some entirely in Lojban. [Lojbanic Community Links|Here] are some interesting sites. Stuff on paper can be ordered from the {ALINK(aname=>LLG)}Logical Language Group{ALINK}; however it is much better if you can retrieve stuff directly off the net. {ANAME()}R4{ANAME}R4.__What messages are appropriate for the Lojban List?__ Beginners are encouraged to post. Anything is appropriate as long as the title approximately reflects the content and you're not selling magazine subscriptions or mail-order brides (exception: even THAT is OK if the post is written in Lojban!). You can post on any subject in Lojban, or about Lojban in any language. You can post in any language you think people will understand. {ANAME()}R5{ANAME}R5.__Are there archives? WWW site? ftp site?__ There are archives of some of the more recent e-mail list messages on this website, while others are stored at Yahoo. See [http://www.lojban.org/resources/forums.html#lists|the mailing lists page]. {ANAME()}R6{ANAME}R6.__What is available in languages other than English?__ There are brochures in Spanish ({file name="Brochure_Spanish1.doc" showdesc=1}), French ({file name="Brochure_French1.doc" showdesc=1}), [http://www.lojban.org/resources/../publications/brochures/brochure_esperanto.html|Esperanto], and [http://www.lojban.org/resources/../publications/brochures/brochure_russian.html|Russian]. Jorge and Jose have translated the ''{ALINK(aname=>gismu)}gismu{ALINK}'' list into Spanish ({file name="Lista_de_gismu_con_definiciones_en_es.doc" showdesc=1}). {ANAME()}R7{ANAME}R7.__What software is available?__ Up-to-date information is available at [http://www.lojban.org/resources/tools.html|the lojban software tools page] on the main site. Below are direct links to some of the software directly associated with the LLG. [http://www.lojban.org/resources/../files/software/logflash.zip|Logflash 1] - teaches ''{ALINK(aname=>gismu)}gismu{ALINK}''; [http://www.lojban.org/resources/../files/software/lfsrc.ZIP|Turbo-Pascal source code] (not well-documented) is available [http://www.lojban.org/resources/../files/software/logfl3.zip|Logflash 3] - teaches ''{ALINK(aname=>cmavo)}cmavo{ALINK}'' [http://www.lojban.org/resources/../files/software/parser/PARSER3.ZIP|Lojban Parser] - the definitive standard of Lojban grammar; verifies the Lojban grammar in a text [http://www.lojban.org/resources/../files/software/gloss3-2.ZIP|Lojban Parser/Glosser] (includes the parser, roughly glosses text to English) [http://www.lojban.org/resources/../files/software/lujvomak.zip|Lujvo-maker program] [http://www.lojban.org/resources/../files/software/analyser|Prolog Semantic Analyzer] [http://www.lojban.org/resources/../files/software/rndsen28.zip|Random Sentence Generator] - updated version in progress, the available version has somewhat obsolete grammar definitions !!TECHNICAL {ANAME()}T1{ANAME}T1.__(Glossary) In English descriptions of ''lojban'', I see ''lojban'' words used, as well as ''lojban'' jargon. What do these mean?__ Here are APPROXIMATE definitions. Note: Words in ALL CAPS on the {ALINK(aname=>lists,pagename=>Lojbanic Forums)}Lojban List{ALINK} often refer to Lojban parts of speech. the English-language phonetic translation of ''''' (single quote) is "h", so when this convention is used, "h" is used as the "capitalization" of '''''. So in English-language discussion, the lojban part of speech contaning the word ''la'e'' (the referent of a sumti) would be "LAhE". ;__{ANAME()}attitudinal{ANAME}attitudinal__:A Lojban interjection (corresponding to "Wow!" or "Eek!" in English, only lojban has many more) ;__{ANAME()}audiovisualisomorphism{ANAME}audiovisual isomorphism__:Used to describe the fact that spoken and written Lojban have the same form ;__''{ANAME()}bridi{ANAME}bridi''__:Lojban sentence~--~a predicate ;__''{ANAME()}brivla{ANAME}brivla''__:Any word that can state a relationship among several objects or concepts, and thus be the core word in a Lojban ''{ALINK(aname=>bridi)}bridi{ALINK}'' - a predicate word ;__''{ANAME()}cmavo{ANAME}cmavo''__:A little word showing structure rather than carrying meaning. The [http://www.lojban.org/resources/../publications/wordlists/cmavo.txt|current cmavo list] is available, but it isn't very easy to read! ;__''{ANAME()}cmene{ANAME}cmene''__:Lojban names ;__{ANAME()}evidential{ANAME}evidential__:Special word indicating how the speaker got their information ;__''{ANAME()}fu'ivla{ANAME}fu'ivla''__:Borrowed word ;__''{ANAME()}gadri{ANAME}gadri''__:Lojban article or determiner~--~signals the start of a ''{ALINK(aname=>sumti)}sumti{ALINK}'' ;__''{ANAME()}gismu{ANAME}gismu''__:Basic 5-letter lojban root word; the basic gismu list is available [http://www.lojban.org/resources/../files/brochures/gismu.html|here] ;__''{ANAME()}JL{ANAME}ju'i lobypli''__ (Attention! Lojbanic Users) (also known as JL):A Lojban newsletter/journal. Publication is currently suspended, but we are hoping to resume publication in future. [http://www.lojban.org/resources/../files/jl|Back issues are available online]. ;__''{ANAME()}LK{ANAME}le lojbo karni''__ (The Lojbanic Journal) (also known as LK):A Lojban newsletter intended to keep our lowest level of supporters informed as to what is going on (in hopes of inspiring greater activity). Also currently suspended. ;__''{ANAME()}le'avla{ANAME}le'avla''__:The old word for ''{ALINK(aname=>fu'ivla)}fu'ivla{ALINK}'' ;__{ANAME()}LLG{ANAME}Logical Language Group (LLG)__: The [The Logical Language Group|Logical Language Group] is legally in charge of the development and maintenance of ''lojban''. It also works to promote the use of ''lojban'' throughout the world. ;__''{ANAME()}lujvo{ANAME}lujvo''__:Compound word ;__{ANAME()}modal{ANAME}modal__:A word for ''{ALINK(aname=>sumtcita)}sumtcita{ALINK}'' whose exact derivation is lost in the history of the Lojban project ;__''{ANAME()}pe'i{ANAME}pe'i''__:An attitudinal meaning "In my opinion" ;__{ANAME()}placestructure{ANAME}place structure__:The specified canonical order of ''{ALINK(aname=>bridi)}bridi{ALINK}'', so that you know who is doing what to whom. ;__''{ANAME()}rafsi{ANAME}rafsi''__:Building block(s) of ''{ALINK(aname=>lujvo)}lujvo{ALINK}'' compound words ;__''{ANAME()}selbri{ANAME}selbri''__:The part of a Lojban sentence that expresses the relationship between the various objects (''{ALINK(aname=>sumti)}sumti{ALINK}'') ;__''{ANAME()}selma'o{ANAME}selma'o''__:Part of speech ;__''{ANAME()}slinku'i{ANAME}slinku'i''__:A hypothetical borrowed word, which would not be legal because it could be interpreted as parts of other words in some contexts. ;__''{ANAME()}sumti{ANAME}sumti''__:An object or idea which may be related to others, that relationship being expressed in a Lojban ''{ALINK(aname=>bridi)}bridi{ALINK}'' ;__''{ANAME()}sumtcita{ANAME}sumtcita''__:Lojban prepositions/adverbs ;__''{ANAME()}tanru{ANAME}tanru''__:A phrase formed of two or more Lojban ''{ALINK(aname=>brivla)}brivla{ALINK}'' ;__{ANAME()}TLI{ANAME}TLI__:[http://www.loglan.org/|The Loglan Institute] {ANAME()}T2{ANAME}T2.__How do you borrow words from other languages?__ There are four ways to borrow words. Only the most common method is covered here; see the [http://www.lojban.org/publications/reference_grammar/chapter4.html#s7|Lojban Reference Grammar (Chapter 4, Section 7)] for more detail. Borrowed words are called ''{ALINK(aname=>fu'ivla)}fu'ivla{ALINK}'', meaning approximately "copied words" (after all, "borrowing" implies we're going to give them back someday!). The use of ''{ALINK(aname=>lujvo)}lujvo{ALINK}'' is not always appropriate for very concrete or specific terms (e. g. "brie," or "cobra"), or for jargon words specialized to a narrow field (e. g. "quark," "integral," or "iambic pentameter"). These words are in effect ''names'' for concepts, and the names were invented by speakers of another language. The vast majority of names for plants, animals, foods, and scientific terminology cannot be easily expressed as ''{ALINK(aname=>tanru)}tanru{ALINK}''. They thus must be "borrowed" (actually, taken) into Lojban from the original language, forming words called ''{ALINK(aname=>fu'ivla)}fu'ivla{ALINK}''. The word must be Lojbanized into one of several permitted ''{ALINK(aname=>rafsi)}rafsi{ALINK}'' is then attached to the beginning of the Lojbanized form, usually using a vocalic consonant as "glue" to ensure that the resulting word doesn't fall apart. The ''{ALINK(aname=>rafsi)}rafsi{ALINK}'' categorizes or limits the meaning of the ''{ALINK(aname=>fu'ivla)}fu'ivla{ALINK}''; otherwise a word having several different jargon meanings in other languages (such as "integral"), would require a choice made as to which meaning should be assigned to the ''{ALINK(aname=>fu'ivla)}fu'ivla{ALINK}''. ''{ALINK(aname=>fu'ivla)}fu'ivla{ALINK}'', like other ''{ALINK(aname=>brivla)}brivla{ALINK}'', are not permitted to have more than one definition. Summarizing the most common method to make ''{ALINK(aname=>fu'ivla)}fu'ivla{ALINK}'': # Lojbanize the word to be borrowed by the methods used for ''{ALINK(aname=>cmene)}cmene{ALINK}''. # Convert all "y"s to some other vowel or to a vocalic consonant. # Modify the ending to be a vowel, either by dropping a final consonant or by adding an extra vowel. # Modify the beginning to be a consonant, either by adding an extra consonant or dropping an initial vowel. # Choose a ''{ALINK(aname=>gismu)}gismu{ALINK}'' (not a ''{ALINK(aname=>rafsi)}rafsi{ALINK}'') that categorizes the ''{ALINK(aname=>fu'ivla)}fu'ivla{ALINK}'' into a "topic area." Replace the final vowel of the ''{ALINK(aname=>gismu)}gismu{ALINK}'' with a vocalic "r". # Prefix the modified ''{ALINK(aname=>fu'ivla)}fu'ivla{ALINK}''. Examples: ||__English__|__''lojban''__ spaghetti|''cidjrspageti'' or ''djarspageti'' maple tree|''tricrmeipli'' maple sugar|''saktrmeipli'' mathematical integral|''cmacrnintegra'' or ''cmacrntegra'' brie|''cirlrbri'' cobra|''sincrkobra'' quark|''saskrkuarka'' iambic|''pemcrniambo''|| A ''{ALINK(aname=>fu'ivla)}fu'ivla{ALINK}'' thus consists of three parts: the classifier, the glue, and the borrowed part The quintessential example is ''djarspageti'', meaning "spaghetti." ''dja'' is the classifier: it is the short form ''{ALINK(aname=>rafsi)}rafsi{ALINK}'' for ''cidja'', meaning "food." "r" is the glue: it is necessary to keep the word from falling into two parts. ''spageti'' is the Lojbanized version of "spaghetti." The classifier is glued on the front for two reasons: it helps identify strange borrowings, and it prevents borrowings that happen to coincide with things that are already Lojban words. For example if you borrowed the word "spageti" directly, it could lead to ambiguity in a phrase like ''ko bevri re spageti palta'' which could mean "Bring two plates of spaghetti" or something like "Be a carrying-reptile and a plate made of this": ''ko bevri respa ge ti palta'' In a natural language there would be no doubt which of the two was meant, but Lojban is constructed so that you shouldn't need to understand the sentence to know where one word ends and the next begins. {ANAME()}T3{ANAME}T3.__Isn't it confusing that some ''{ALINK(aname=>rafsi)}rafsi{ALINK}'' are identical to ''{ALINK(aname=>cmavo)}cmavo{ALINK}''?__ No, it isn't. In theory you can tell completely from the neighboring syllables whether something is a ''{ALINK(aname=>rafsi)}rafsi{ALINK}''. This is how the computer is able to parse Lojban without understanding its meaning. For example the ''dei'' in ''bavlamdei'' ("tomorrow") is a ''{ALINK(aname=>rafsi)}rafsi{ALINK}'' for "day," not the ''{ALINK(aname=>cmavo)}cmavo{ALINK}''''dei'', a special pronoun meaning "this sentence." We know which is which because Lojban words can't end in a consonant, so ''dei''''must'' be a part of ''bavlamdei''; "bavLAM" can't be a whole word. (No, it can't be a name, either. Names end with a consonant followed by a pause, written as a "''.''") In practice you can also use your knowledge of the meanings of the words to help with this; it is possible to think up a sentence like ''la bavLAM. dei cusku'', "Bavlam says this sentence.", but it is not likely in practice if you don't know anyone named "Bavlam"! {ANAME()}T4{ANAME}T4.__Why do some texts use "h" instead of ''''' (single quote), or have parentheses, or other non-standard conventions?__ Aesthetic reasons. ((And Rosta)) in particular thinks ''mohi'' looks better in print than ''mo'i'' (space motion) and sometimes uses it the hopes that he can influence the ((Lojbanic Community Links|Lojban community)) to accept this other spelling convention. This is purely a difference in spelling; they are pronounced the same, and should be considered different ways of writing the same "letter." This alternate spelling also is somewhat closer to the spelling of [The Loglan Institute|TLI] Loglan. There is another similar spelling convention, which has never been used, designed to make Lojban look more familiar to potential converts from [The Loglan Institute|TLI]. This alternate convention may be found in the [http://www.lojban.org/publications/reference_grammar/chapter3.html#s12|Lojban Reference Grammar]. There are a number of other non-standard spelling conventions: ((And Rosta)) has (or at least ''had'') a style in which ''''' (single quote) is omitted altogether where the vowels couldn't possibly be stuck together; for example, he'd write ''coe'' for ''co'e'' (unspecified bridi), since "oe" is not a legal combination. He has used "." (period) as in English, to end a sentence, rather than as a pause. He has capitalized the first word of the sentence. ((Xod)) often uses / (a forward slash) or parentheses to mark clauses out when writing in lojban. He also uses a single capital letter for acronyms instead of the lojban letterals (i.e. A instead of .abu.). There have been others. In general, they are all quite understandable by a competent lojbanic person, with the possible exception of And's removal of ''''' (single quote). {ANAME()}T5{ANAME}T5.__Why does it have a special meaning when the ''{ALINK(aname=>selbri)}selbri{ALINK}'' comes first?__ In Loglan it used to be a command, but now we use either ''ko'' (imperative) or {ALINK(aname=>attitudinal)}attitudinals{ALINK}. In a simple bridi, having the selbri at the beginning make it an observative, which means you are stating that you are observing the relationship in question (much like saying "Fire!" in English, except without necessarily carrying emotional connotations). In a ''poi broda'' (which does/is something-or-other) phrase, it is likely that you'll want x{SUB()}1{SUB} to be ''ke'a'' and to explicitly state x{SUB()}2{SUB}. If verb-initial ordering (also called V-initial) wasn't special, and if syntax within a ''poi'' (restrictive clause) was consistent with sentence-level syntax, then you'd have to explicitly use ''fe'' (second sumti place) or ''zo'e'' (unspecified it) or ''ke'a'' to get to the x{SUB()}2{SUB}. For example, now we say ''le nanmu poi prami mi'' (The man which loves me) and the x{SUB()}1{SUB} of ''prami'' (love) is elided, and we can assume it is ''ke'a'', which here equals ''le nanmu'' (The/a man/men). Without this special treatment of V-initial, we'd have to say ''le nanmu poi ke'a prami mi'' (The man which loves me) or ''le nanmu poi ke'a mi prami.'' (The man which loves me) So: it saves 2 syllables in what is arguably the most common way of using ''poi'' (restrictive clause). May or may not be worth it, depending on how you value word-order flexibility vs. brevity. In general it lets you easily get to x{SUB()}2{SUB} in sentences without an x{SUB()}1{SUB}. Remember: There's always more than one way to do it in ''lojban''. {ANAME()}T6{ANAME}T6.__Why are there so many words for AND? Why not just let "''.e''" (and, between sumti) connect two ''{ALINK(aname=>bridi)}bridi{ALINK}'', ''bridi''-tails (a predicate and a sumti), or anything else?__ We use different connectives for different scopes. Doing so helps the listener keep track of what exactly the speaker wants connected. This is ''much'' more important in speech than in text, because in text you can re-read and ponder. If you have a multi-part nested ''{ALINK(aname=>sumti)}sumti{ALINK}'' joined to another multi-part nested ''{ALINK(aname=>sumti)}sumti{ALINK}'', having clear indicators of scope may make the sentence understandable when otherwise it is not. It is therefore hoped that spoken Lojban and written Lojban can be similar in level of complexity. (You know, {ALINK(aname=>audiovisualisomorphism)}audiovisual isomorphism{ALINK}.) {ANAME()}T7{ANAME}T7.__Is the 's' at the end of lojbanized names (such as 'noras.') silent?__ No. 'noras.' is really pronounced with an 's' at the end. Some languages can borrow names with virtually no changes, but Lojban is one of the languages that sometimes requires quite heavy modification of the names. Specifically, all Lojban words of the class ''{ALINK(aname=>cmene)}cmene{ALINK}'' must always end in a consonant. Sometimes, this requires removing a vowel at the end, or adding a consonant. By convention, this is often 's', but it could be any consonant. If names were not changed this way, some of them could be mistaken for other words, or sequences of words. In this case, were there no 's' at the end, 'nora' would read as 'no ra', ie. "none of them"! This distinction is as important in speech as in writing, so names, as any other Lojban word, must be pronounced exactly as written. There are no silent letters in Lojban. !!PROJECT STATUS {ANAME()}PS1{ANAME}PS1.__What parts of the language are well worked out, and which parts are in flux?__ As of 1997, the language design has been baselined for a minimum of 5 years after the publication of the three books: the reference grammar, the dictionary, and the textbook. Since the latter two are not near publication, this means that no changes to the language will even be considered until at least 2006. This baseline is non-negotiable, even if we enter into discussions with The Loglan Institute to reunite the Loglan community now that ((James Cooke Brown|JCB)) has passed on. The phonology, orthography, and morphology have been essentially stable since 1988, except for a slight change in what counts as a legal ''{ALINK(aname=>fu'ivla)}fu'ivla{ALINK}''. The [http://www.lojban.org/publications/wordlists/gismu.txt|''gismu'' list] has been stable since 1988, except that about 25 ''{ALINK(aname=>gismu)}gismu{ALINK}'' have been added and 2 ''{ALINK(aname=>gismu)}gismu{ALINK}'' had minor changes up until 1994, but since then only clarifications of confusing wording have been made to the official [http://www.lojban.org/publications/wordlists/gismu.txt|baseline ''gismu'' list], and they are now considered baselined. The ''{ALINK(aname=>rafsi)}rafsi{ALINK}'' have been unchanged since 1993, when around 20% were changed in a final tuning before baselining them. Much existing text has not been updated after the ''{ALINK(aname=>rafsi)}rafsi{ALINK}'' change, so texts dated before 1993 may be confusing. The grammar has been basically stable since 1993, was under careful documented control after that date, and frozen with the publication of ((The Complete Lojban Language)) in 1997. The [http://www.lojban.org/publications/wordlists/cmavo.txt|''cmavo'' list] has been baselined since 1997, though new compounds may be defined through usage. The only area not frozen is the addition of new words to the lexicon through borrowing (''{ALINK(aname=>lujvo)}lujvo{ALINK}''). Those two productive areas are open-ended; a primary limitation on the language definition is the inability to record and define new coinings as fast as they are invented. The basic semantics of the language are stable. There are still ongoing disputes about "how to say it best in Lojban"; we expect these to continue indefinitely. As a matter of policy, changes even to Lojban non-baselined usages, if they would require people to re-learn things, are resisted vigorously. Almost anything that practical people (i.e. beginners) would actually use is well worked out, debugged and stable. Points of controversy include highly technical philosophical issues such as whether empty sets are or are not excluded as the candidate referent set of a ''{ALINK(aname=>sumti)}sumti{ALINK}'', or whether current grammar is adequate to represent all possible forms of indirect questions. The answers are very important to the language definition (no joke), but people have been speaking natural languages for years without knowing the answers, so don't worry about Lojban. And you don't have to know what lambda calculus is. The major point of controversy that is significant to beginners is a feeling in some quarters that the policies used to design the place (argument, ''{ALINK(aname=>gismu)}gismu{ALINK}'' (basic predicate words) were not exactly optimal. Sometimes the semantics of the less-used places are at issue. Officially, we'll go with what we have to preserve the investment people have made in learning the language, and after the baseline period is over, those who are actually speaking the language will be allowed to discuss changes in Lojban. There are no plans to ever seriously discuss changes to the language other than in Lojban. {ANAME()}PS2{ANAME}PS2.__What are the most current revisions of each part of the language descriptions?__ The versions found on the [http://www.lojban.org|Lojban web site] are definitive, except that the printed version of ((The Lojban Reference Grammar)) ( which is called ((The Complete Lojban Language)) ) takes precedence over the HTML version. Working drafts of books in preparation are maintained on ''lojbab's'' home computers, and may be slightly updated from the on-line versions. {ANAME()}PS3{ANAME}PS3.__What projects are being worked on? When will they be done?__ ((The Complete Lojban Language)) is of course complete and published. For a current list of ongoing projects, see the ((Official LLG Projects)) page, the ((Old LLG Committees)) page, and ((ongoing projects|the wiki ongoing projects page)). __''WHEN?''__ Projects are all being done by volunteers, and therefore will be done when people finish them. We've promised dates in the past and invariably been wrong. The priorities are for the dictionary and the introductory materials book, with the latter more likely to come out earlier than the former. Publication of books is severely hampered by finances (anyone with money is welcome to ((sarji fo lo jdini|donate))!), and the lack of ability to publish in the short term has tended to hurt motivation and productivity of those working on those publications. {ANAME()}PS4{ANAME}PS4.__What can I do to help?__ A few possibilities: * Post beginner questions on the {ALINK(aname=>lists,pagename=>Lojbanic Forums)}Lojban List{ALINK} and don't be intimidated * Tell about yourself and your interests (in Lojban preferably, but English is OK) on the {ALINK(aname=>lists,pagename=>Lojbanic Forums)}Lojban List{ALINK} * Write in Lojban on the {ALINK(aname=>lists,pagename=>Lojbanic Forums)}Lojban List{ALINK} * Write something in Lojban (Try to write something new~--~((Translations|translation of literature)) is not generally a good or easy beginner exercise). * Study Lojban vocabulary using LogFlash or flashcards * Come to {ALINK(aname=>G5)}LogFest{ALINK} in July/August in Fairfax VA (near Washington, DC), USA. * Try expressing yourself in Lojban * Invite others to join a live {ALINK(aname=>irc,pagename=>Lojbanic Forums)}IRC chat{ALINK} in or about Lojban * Keep a diary in Lojban * Check out the ((Official LLG Projects|Projects)) and the ((Old LLG Committees|Committees)) pages for new and ongoing projects * Send money to the {ALINK(aname=>LLG)}LLG{ALINK} using PayPal !!HISTORICAL {ANAME()}H1{ANAME}H1.__How was the default {ALINK(aname=>selbri)}selbri{ALINK}'' determined? (There does not appear to be any rhyme or reason for the order of ''{ALINK(aname=>gismu)}gismu{ALINK}''.)__ They went through a lot of revisions; it is something in-between planning and evolution. There is a considerable amount of system there, but it is ill-documented. The nice thing to know is that you don't have to memorize the {ALINK(aname=>placestructure)}place structures{ALINK}. Just using the language, you will come to have a feel for which places are present and in what order. Most people who take the time to become familiar with the language find that with practice, they begin to develop a sense of what the place structures ought to be. Conveniently, their sense usually matches up with the definition. {ANAME()}H2{ANAME}H2.__How did the ''{ALINK(aname=>gismu)}gismu{ALINK}'' get made: discussion, etymology examples?__ There is a ((gismu Etymology|full set of etymologies)) on the file server. There is some explanation available, including [http://www.lojban.org/files/etymology/etysample.txt|samples] (broken link), and a more verbose description in the [http://lojban.org/publications/level0/brochure/lingissues.html#idx452|Level 0 package] and at the ((Lojban Etymology|Lojban Etymology Information)) page. The etymologies in 6 languages and the scoring for each language are given, in order Chinese/English/Hindi/Spanish/Russian/Arabic~--~a 0 score means that the language made no contribution to the word, and thus its etymological keyword did not matter. The languages were weighted. While new ''{ALINK(aname=>gismu)}gismu{ALINK}'' are not being made, ''lojbab'' updates the weighting based on estimated numbers of first and second language speakers every couple of years. The original and 1999 weights are available [http://www.lojban.org/publications/etymology/langstat99.htm|online]. {ANAME()}H3{ANAME}H3.__What is the difference between Loglan and Lojban? How is Loglan-82 related?__ James Cooke Brown ( ((James Cooke Brown|JCB)) ) came up with the idea of Loglan in the 1940s and starting inventing the language around 1955. It has been evolving ever since. In 1982-4 or so there was a political disagreement and the Loglan community fell apart. A couple of years later, Bob LeChevalier (''lojbab''), then working with ((James Cooke Brown|JCB)), attempted to resurrect the community. This led to a falling out based on ((James Cooke Brown|JCB))'s proprietary intellectual property claims on the language. The community split into two efforts, with ((James Cooke Brown|JCB)) at the head of of the Loglan effort, {ALINK(aname=>TLI)}The Loglan Institute (TLI){ALINK}, and (''lojbab'') at the head of the Lojban effort, the {ALINK(aname=>LLG)}Logical Language Group (LLG){ALINK}. The latter is Lojban, which {ALINK(aname=>LLG)}LLG{ALINK} (backed up by a court decision) considers a subcategory of Loglan. Sadly, ((James Cooke Brown|JCB)) passed away in 2000. It is unclear if the Loglan organization has leadership capable of sustaining the effort. A more lengthy discussion of the issues can be found in the article ((The Loglan-Lojban Dispute)), and in ''{ALINK(aname=>JL)}ju'i lobypli{ALINK}'' (Attention! Lojbanic Users). ''lojbab'' makes occasional efforts to spark discussion that would lead to reunification of the efforts behind Lojban, although no consideration will be given to abandoning the Lojban baseline. Loglan-82 is a completely unrelated computer language developed in Poland by people unaware of the existence of the Loglan/Lojban project. {ANAME()}H4{ANAME}H4.__Why do older Lojban texts (before 1993) not make much sense sometimes?__ Lojban has been quite stable since 1992-3, when the last significant changes were made (since then, most "changes" have been additions to the language which did not make older text invalid). The last changes to the ''{ALINK(aname=>gismu)}gismu{ALINK}'' list were made in 1992, and in 1993 the ''{ALINK(aname=>rafsi)}rafsi{ALINK}'' in Lojban word-making. There is a [http://www.lojban.org/files/history/bothraf.txt|translation table] from the older ''{ALINK(aname=>rafsi)}rafsi{ALINK}'' to the final set. !! PRONUNCIATION {ANAME()}B1{ANAME}B1.__I'm not quite sure I understand the written descriptions of how the vowels sound.__ Here is a link to [http://perpetuum-immobile.de/vowels_aleks.ogg|a vowel sound file in Ogg Vorbis format].