History: Reduction of the number of selma'o

Preview of version: 2

The words of Lojban are classified, according to their grammar, in 124 selma'o (counting BRIVLA and CMENE). This number of grammar classes is excesive, and can be easily reduced without any noticeable effect in the expressiveness of the language (and in many cases with some increase in it). These 55 selma'o could be eliminated or merged with other selma'o, thereby reducing the complexity of the syntax, and thus making it easier to learn. (Arguments for each of these actions have been presented in different places, and I may in the future try to collect them here or provide links. For the moment I am only recording the list. Discussion about the general idea of selma'o number reduction or about particular cases is welcome in the discussion forum of this page. mi'e xorxes )

selma'o recommended action backwards compatibility
A merge with JOI yes (with adjustment to allow NA JOI)
BIhE eliminate no
BIhI merge with JOI almost
CAhA merge with BAI yes
CAI merge with UI yes
CEI eliminate no
CEhE eliminate no
COI merge with DOI yes
CUhE merge with BAI yes
DAhO merge with UI yes
FAhA merge with BAI yes
FOI eliminate/merge with BY no/yes
FUhA eliminate no
FUhE merge with UI yes
FUhO merge with UI yes
GAhO merge with UI almost
GUhA eliminate no
JA merge with JOI yes (with adjustment to allow NA JOI)
JOhI eliminate no
KI merge with BAI yes
KUhE eliminate no
LA merge with LE almost
LAU eliminate/merge with BY no/yes
LOhO eliminate/merge with BOI no/yes
MAhO eliminate no
MEhU merge with MOI almost
MOhE eliminate no
MOhI merge with FEhE yes
NAI merge with UI yes
NAhU eliminate no
NIhE eliminate no
NIhO merge with I yes
NUhA eliminate no
NUhI eliminate no
NUhU eliminate no
PEhE eliminate no
PEhO eliminate no
PU merge with BAI yes
RAhO merge with UI yes
SA eliminate no
SOI eliminate no
TAhE merge with BAI yes
TEhU eliminate no
TEI eliminate/merge with BY no/yes
VA merge with BAI yes
VEI eliminate no
VEhO eliminate no
VUhU eliminate no
VEhA merge with BAI yes
VIhA eliminate/merge with BAI no/yes
ZAhO merge with BAI yes
ZEhA merge with BAI yes
ZI merge with BAI yes
BRIVLA merge with GOhA yes
CMENE merge with GOhA almost


The surviving selma'o are:

BAI BAhE BE BEI BEhO BO BOI BU BY CO CU DOI DOhU FA FAhO FEhE FEhU FIhO GA GEhU GI GIhA GOI
GOhA I JAI JOI KE KEhE KEI KOhA KU KUhO LAhE LE LEhU LI LIhU LOhU LU LUhU MAI ME MOI NA NAhE
NOI NU PA ROI SE SEI SEhU SI SU TO TOI TUhE TUhU UI VAU VUhO XI Y ZEI ZIhE ZO ZOI ZOhU

History

Advanced
Information Version
Fri 01 of Jun, 2007 22:49 GMT xorxes from 200.117.153.124 3
Thu 31 of May, 2007 22:28 GMT xorxes from 200.117.154.87 2
Mon 28 of May, 2007 23:33 GMT xorxes from 190.30.128.87 1
Show PHP error messages