WikiDiscuss

Posted by xorxes on Thu 20 of May, 2004 13:46 GMT posts: 1912

(I did not receive this discuss message from pc in my mailbox,
I found it just by chance.)

pc:
...
> la
> Can we fit a quantifier between {la} and the cmevla/selbri
> without getting the name wrong? How?

A quantifier is not grammatical between {la} and a cmevla.
It is grammatical between {la} and a selbri. (Why there should
be a distinction, I don't know. I think CMENE should have the
same grammar as BRIVLA.)

As for interpretation, {la ci cribe} can be either "the three
that I call 'bear'" or "the one I call 'three bears'". I'm not
sure we really need to impose one of them.

> <<lo'e
> le'e
> >>
>
> I am unsure just what to make of enumerating typical and
> stereotypical whatsises. The pattern seems to call for it, but
> in the cases where plurality plays a role, it seems to me that
> the typicality (etc.) is predicative not descriptive. That is you
> really want such things not just using the locution to talk in
> generalities about whatsises ? whether or not they exist.

I'm not sure what to make of it either. I'm not sure I follow
what you say. Perhaps a couple of examples of how you think
they should be used would be useful.

mu'o mi'e xorxes

On Thu, May 20, 2004 at 06:46:52AM -0700, wikidiscuss@lojban.org wrote:
> Re: BPFK section:gadri
>
> (I did not receive this discuss message from pc in my mailbox, I found
> it just by chance.)

That's because his mailer sent it to both the wrong recipient
(wikidiscuss@lojban.org instead of wikidiscuss-list@lojban.org, which is
what's actually in the Reply-To) and the wrong subject
('BPFK section:gadri' instead of 'BPFK section: gadri').

wikidiscuss@lojban.org is the account that sucks posts into the Wiki.
wikidiscuss-list@lojban.org is the mailing list, and has
wikidiscuss@lojban.org as one of its members.

PC:

If your mailer completely ignores "Reply-To", it's broken. And I don't
mean 'broken' in the "I'm an elitest snob and you should do what I say"
sense, I mean 'broken' in the "every mailer I've ever heard of,
including all web-based mailers, Outlook, and Outlook Express, can all
do this" sense.

If your mailer randomly drops spaces out of subject lines, it's even
more broken than that.

-Robin