History: ''ca'ai'', ''ka'ei'' and ''nu'oi', and ''nau'a''

Source of version: 1 (current)

(A), (B) and (C) are alternatives. 1. "In some possible worlds (in which q is the case), possibly including This World, p" A. ''su'o mu'ei'' B. ''ka'ei'' C. ''ka'e'' 2. "In some possible worlds (in which q is the case), including This World, p" A. ''nau'a'' B. ''ca'ai'' C. ''ca'a'' 3. "In some possible worlds (in which q is the case), not including This World, p" A. ''na ku nau'a su'o mu'ei''??? -- or ''nau'a nai''??? B. ''nu'oi'' C. ''nu'o'' On the face of things, option C would be preferred, rendering ''ca'ai'', ''ka'ei'', ''nu'oi'' and ''nau'a'' redundant. And some people's understanding of ''ca'a'' et al is consistent with this. The snag is that ''ca'a'' et al are understood by others (including ma'oste gloss and Woldy) to involve an element of capability. * I should add that I believe that originally ''ca'a/ka'e/nu'o'' were intended to have the meanings given above under (C), and the notion of capability crept in through a failure of understanding which then got cemented in official documents. * But the argument pro pattern C is being revived: see ((CAhA as sumtcita)). * On the ((CAhA as sumtcita)) page, I argue for 1 = A ''mu'ei'', 2 = C ''ca'a'', 3 = C ''nu'o''. Therefore I am not in favour of any of ''ca'ai'', ''ka'ei'', ''nu'oi'' and ''nau'a''. --((And))

History

Enable pagination rows per page

HTML diff Side-by-side diff Side-by-side diff by characters Inline diff Inline diff by characters Full side-by-side diff Full side-by-side diff by characters Full inline diff Full inline diff by characters Unified diff Side-by-side view HTML diff Side-by-side diff Advanced

Information	Version
Fri 30 of Nov, 2001 12:31 GMT admin from admin created from phpwiki import	1

Select action to perform with checked... Remove OK